In this Human Resources series, we explore topical issues facing HR managers today, helping them overcome the most significant workplace challenges, such as ensuring fair and equal recruitment. Every day, thousands of training buyers, including HR and learning teams, visit findcourses.com to find the ideal courses to meet their needs. Combined with our proprietary research, this positions us uniquely to offer valuable insights into these challenges.
Have you ever seen or experienced workplace bias? You're not alone. In their 2024 Work in America survey, the American Psychological Association highlighted the chasm between employees who feel psychologically safe and those who don’t. Among their findings, the report states that 24% of employees living with a cognitive, emotional, learning, or mental disability feel their workplace environment is toxic, compared to 14% of respondents without any disability. Additionally, only 80% of survey respondents in the low psychological safety group were satisfied with their organization’s diversity, equity and inclusion policies, compared to 96% in the high psychological safety group. Whether it's a subtle preference for certain backgrounds or outright discrimination based on race, gender, or age, many workers still encounter unfair practices.
Bias can begin in the hiring process where the university a prospective applicant attended, the part of town where they live, or even their last name can influence whether they get called for an interview. This is where Artificial Intelligence can help. With AI technology, HR professionals can screen information that could lead to bias and enable hiring decisions based solely on a candidate’s skill and expertise.
At findcourses, we have seen a staggering 550% increase in AI course searches on our site, according to our 2024 Course Trends and Skills report, so in this article, we ask HR professionals and AI experts whether they think AI will help or hinder diversity efforts in the recruitment process. We will explore potential workplace biases, discuss challenges, and provide actionable strategies.
Understanding Bias in Traditional HR Practices
Bias can manifest in several forms, including unconscious bias and systemic bias. These biases can significantly impact organizations, leading to a lack of diversity and stifling creativity and innovation. Let's begin by defining two main biases:
- Unconscious bias is the automatic, implicit stereotypes and attitudes that can unconsciously influence our understanding, actions, and decisions.
- Systemic bias involves ingrained institutional policies and practices that disadvantage certain groups.
HR policies can reduce systematic bias in organizations; however, unconscious bias is more challenging to address, so we contacted some HR teams to learn about their experiences. Jessica Munday, People and Culture Manager at Custom Neon, a global retailer and manufacturer of custom-designed LED neon lights and signs, says, "Without proper checks, there can sometimes be a tendency for managers to favor candidates who share similar backgrounds or experiences as their own."
Another example of unconscious bias, according to Stephen Greet, CEO and co-founder of resume-building company BeamJobs, is the "propensity [of some organizations] to give preference to applicants from affluent backgrounds or prestigious universities, even when their credentials or abilities might not always match the job requirements."
However, the cost of unfair decisions is high for individuals and organizations. In their report, ‘Understanding the Effects of Discrimination in the Workplace,’ Gallup states that “discrimination, understandably, drains employees' motivation, commitment to their jobs and their engagement.” Thus, unfair choices result in lower engagement for individuals, especially from employees within marginalized groups. Additionally, the financial cost is heavy for organizations. Disengagement and lack of productivity can cost the global economy up to $7 trillion, and organizations that fail to address bias in their HR practices can face serious legal repercussions, including discrimination lawsuits and long-lasting reputational damage.
Awareness of bias is crucial; therefore, managers at every level must acknowledge unconscious biases they or others in their organization might hold. Munday says: "We've been cautious at Custom Neon to spot these kinds of prejudices... [as] the first step in our endeavor to establish a workplace that is more fair and inclusive". Likewise, Greet says BeamJobs has also implemented procedures to eliminate prejudices and ensure impartial hiring, promotion, and layoff decisions. Unconscious bias training is a good place to start for anybody in a leadership or decision-making role.
HR managers play a critical role in evening the playing field. They must self-reflect on their processes, seek the opinions of diverse panels when making decisions, and join Diversity and Inclusion Programs to educate themselves further.
Find your next course
AI's Role in Mitigating Bias
Reducing bias is essential for creating a fair and inclusive environment. AI technology offers promising solutions to help achieve this goal by ensuring algorithmic fairness, improving recruitment processes, and providing objective performance metrics. By leveraging these advancements, organizations can promote equity, minimize unconscious bias, and make more informed, unbiased decisions.
- Algorithmic Fairness: Developers can minimize bias by using diverse training data and implementing fairness constraints in AI algorithms. This will lead to more equitable outcomes.
- Blind Recruitment: AI tools for blind recruitment anonymize candidate information, helping recruiters focus on skills and qualifications rather than demographic characteristics. This reduces unconscious bias in hiring decisions.
- Performance Metrics: AI can use employee performance data to assess decisions regarding promotions or layoffs fairly. This helps remove biases and makes sure people are judged on their skills.
Many HR teams using AI technology can testify to successful outcomes. Daniel Meursing, CEO and Founder of Los Angeles-based staffing agency Premier Staff, used an AI-powered resume screening tool to curate a pool of candidates based solely on their merits. "The results were remarkable," he says. Our hiring decisions were more diverse and inclusive than ever before, and we onboarded exceptional talent that may have been overlooked in traditional screening processes."
Enhancing your HR procedures with AI knowledge and technology is increasingly essential in today's data-driven world. It provides a competitive edge and enables more effective, equitable decision-making. Don’t forget, if you are an individual or organization looking to explore AI's potential, you can search and compare various AI courses on findcourses!
Find your next course
Challenges and Ethical Considerations for HR Managers
[A]n AI system ... will only be as effective as the training data it learned from. If a system was trained with biased data, then it's going to produce biased output and may end up just reinforcing the biases already present in an organization rather than helping to undo them.
- Rob Boyle, Marketing Operations Director, Airswift
AI will undoubtedly contribute significantly towards an equal workplace, but challenges and ethical considerations must be addressed to ensure effective and fair use. A major challenge, for example, is the potential for AI systems to inherit or amplify biases in their training data. This means that human thinking can negatively influence AI technology, something that organizations must strive to eliminate.
BeamJob’s Stephen Greet points out another issue: "An AI system might find it difficult, for example, to understand the worth and resiliency of someone who took a career break to care for a family member or the distinct viewpoints and problem-solving skills acquired from unusual professional paths and life events".
Therefore, organizations should implement regular audits and explain how AI systems make decisions to ensure fairness and build stakeholder trust. This emphasis on regular audits and transparency should reassure HR professionals and AI experts about the fairness of AI systems. Potential AI bias issues can be mitigated by using diverse datasets, incorporating fairness constraints, and conducting regular bias assessments during development.
One thing is clear: organizations must not rely on AI alone. A hybrid approach in which AI assists human decision-makers is essential. Custom Neon’s Jess Munday says, "to guarantee the continuous objectivity and openness of our HR processes, we carefully strike a balance between human judgment and automated systems."
The bottom line is that combining AI's efficiency with humans' critical thinking and ethical considerations ensures that final decisions are well-rounded and ethically sound.
Strategies for Integrating AI Responsibly in HR Processes
Several vital strategies can ensure a smooth and effective transition for HR companies looking to integrate AI into their processes. "HR has an opportunity to lead transformation and change," says Katie Obi, Chief People Officer at OneAdvanced, a supplier of business software. Obi believes the first step is identifying areas where AI can add the most value, such as recruitment, performance evaluation, or employee retention.
The next step is to invest in quality AI training to ensure your team understands the technology and its potential biases. "We all have a responsibility to educate ourselves", Obi continues “to understand upcoming legislation, to consider ethics, responsibility, transparency and bias, and to understand the impact this will have on our customers, society, go-to-market strategies, people and productivity."
Thus, HR teams should partner with reputable AI vendors who prioritize algorithmic fairness and transparency when choosing AI tools. Finally, HR should implement a pilot program to test that AI tools function correctly and ethically within a controlled environment before a full-scale rollout.
In conclusion, unconscious and systemic biases can lead to unfair decisions and legal repercussions for organizations. AI technology, however, presents promising solutions to mitigate bias in HR decision-making. By exploring and investing in AI technologies and training, organizations can enhance their HR strategies, make more informed decisions, and ultimately foster a more diverse and inclusive environment.
Find your next course
